Collodi joined the FC Dallas academy in 2015 and remained until 2019, when he committed to playing collegiate soccer at Columbia University. He was an immediate starter as a freshman and ended his college career with 58 appearances, all starts, across four seasons. He was named Honorable Mention All-Ivy League in 2021 and 2022, and Second Team All-Ivy League in 2023. He ranks second all-time in career saves at Columbia with 237.[2]
Club career
In January 2024, after graduating college, Collodi signed with North Texas SC, FC Dallas’ developmental team in MLS Next Pro.[3] In his first professional season, he made 27 appearances, recording 90 saves, five clean sheets, and 17 wins. He was named the 2024 MLS Next Pro Goalkeeper of the Year.[4]
On January 9, 2025, Collodi signed a Homegrown Player contract with FC Dallas.[5] He made his Major League Soccer debut on March 22, 2025, starting in a 1–0 victory over Real Salt Lake while first-choice goalkeeper Maarten Paes was on international duty with Indonesia.[6]