Reviews
Critics were generally positive over Saturn Bomberman. It received enthusiastic reviews from Electronic Gaming Monthly's four-person "review crew", Saturn Power's Dean Mortlock, and Sega Saturn Magazine's Matt Yeo, who were particularly impressed with the ten-player capability[9][14][15] and the numerous modes and options.[14][15] Yeo also praised the game's accessibility, remarking, "Mastering power-ups and building on that initial buzz certainly adds to the game's broad appeal but the fact that players can simply pick up a joypad and leap straight into the thick of things with the minimum of tuition is the real winning factor."[15] However, a reviewer for Next Generation and Jeff Gerstmann of GameSpot both felt the game failed to break out from the shadow of Super Bomberman 2. Gerstmann elaborated, "Since that classic game, every subsequent Bomberman game has closely mirrored it, while tacking on a few silly features that kept the game fresh without really adding anything useful. Saturn Bomberman combines all these silly features into one game, giving you what should be the ultimate Bomberman game. But any serious Bomberman player has seen all this before."[11] Next Generation similarly opined that "the basic gameplay goodness of the series isn't tarnished, but nevertheless, the latest offering from Hudson Soft doesn't attain the classic status of SB2."[12]
Critics were also not wholly sold on the 10-player feature, as most noted that the screen size used for ten players makes powerups and characters too small to discern on all but the largest television sets.[11][12][15][17] They nonetheless concurred that the multiplayer modes overall are the highlight of the game.[9][11][12][14][15][17] Dan Hsu of Electronic Gaming Monthly stated that "It's a mediocre one-player game. It's a fantastic multiplayer game. And that's all you really need to know."[9] Mortlock ventured that it is "Probably the best multi-player game you'll ever play."[14] GamePro noted that the screen is much less confusing if there are eight players or fewer, and commented, "If you don't have a Sega multitap, Saturn Bomberman offers the perfect excuse to get one. If you don't have friends, this is a good opportunity to get some of them, too."[17]
The Story Mode and Master Mode were criticized by Matt Yeo for the frustratingly difficult AI and unforgiving boss fights,[15] and GamePro similarly described them as "more a trial of your patience than a test of your skill."[17] However, Next Generation contended that these modes are the one area where Saturn Bomberman actually exceeds Super Bomberman 2, as they "offer a decidedly less frantic (but more cerebral) puzzle-gamelike experience".[12]
Critics generally remarked that the graphics and music are very limited and fail to advance the Bomberman series in any way.[11][12][17] Most also complained at the excessive length of time between the game's original release in Japan and its release in North America and Europe.[9][11][14][15]
Next Generation reviewed the Japanese version of the game as an import in 1996, rating it four stars out of five, and stated that "even a mediocre Bomberman game is still worth checking out, and a must for gregarious Saturn fans."[18] In Japan, the game sold 129,616 units.[19]
Accolades
In Electronic Gaming Monthly's 100th issue, Saturn Bomberman would tie with Castlevania: Symphony of the Night for Game of the Month.[20] Later that year, the magazine would award Saturn Bomberman the 1997 Game of the Year awards for "Saturn Game of the Year" and "Multiplayer Game of the Year".[16] The same year, Electronic Gaming Monthly listed it as the 10th best console video game of all time, remarking that while it was only slightly better than the Bomberman games for the older Super NES and TurboGrafx-16, it was nonetheless the best entry in the series to date.[21]. Digitiser ranked it the second best Saturn game of 1997, below Fighters Megamix.[13]
In 2008, IGN ranked Saturn Bomberman eight on their "Top 10 Sega Saturn Games" list, and in 2009 called it the best Bomberman game along with Bomberman '93.[22][23] In 2012, GamesRadar ranked the game fourth on their "Best Saturn games of all time" list.[24] In 2014, Retro Gamer placed the game on their "Top Ten Saturn Games" list.[25]