Thamel joined The New York Times in 2003 and spent nine years there as the national college sports reporter. In 2006, The New York Times nominated him for a Pulitzer Prize for national reporting. He left the Times in 2012 for Sports Illustrated as a senior writer, covering college football and basketball.[7][8] Thamel joined Yahoo Sports in 2017 and covered college sports and the NFL.[9][10]
Thamel is a member of the Football Writers Association of America and has won numerous FWAA writing awards.[11] He has also won several Associated Press Sports Editors (APSE) awards,[12] including first place for beat reporting in 2017 and breaking news in 2011. He considers Peter King at Sports Illustrated and Joe Drape from The New York Times his biggest mentors.[2]