| Team |
Performance vs. Opponent |
Year |
| Most points scored |
56, Appalachian State vs. North Texas |
2020 |
| Fewest points allowed |
6, Western Michigan vs. Kennesaw State |
2025 |
| Margin of victory |
35, Western Michigan vs. Kennesaw State |
2025 |
| First downs |
35, Tulsa vs. Old Dominion |
2021 |
| Total yards |
638, Appalachian State vs. North Texas |
2020 |
| Rushing yards |
502, Appalachian State vs. North Texas |
2020 |
| Passing yards |
350, Georgia Southern vs. Ohio |
2023 |
| Most points scored (losing team) |
28, North Texas vs. Appalachian State |
2020 |
| Most points scored (both teams) |
84, Appalachian State vs. North Texas |
2020 |
| Fewest yards allowed |
247, Old Dominion vs. Tulsa |
2021 |
| Fewest rushing yards allowed |
33, Ohio vs. Georgia Southern |
2023 |
| Fewest passing yards allowed |
93, Marshall vs. UConn |
2022 |
| Individual |
Player (Team) |
Year |
| Points scored |
30, shared by: Camerun Peoples (Appalachian State) Rickey Hunt (Ohio) |
2020 2023 |
| All-Purpose yards |
317, Camerun Peoples (Appalachian State) |
2020 |
| Rushing yards |
317, Camerun Peoples (Appalachian State) |
2020 |
| Passing yards |
350, Davis Brin (Georgia Southern) |
2023 |
| Receiving yards |
131, Austin Ogunmakin (North Texas) |
2020 |
| Touchdowns (all-purpose) |
5, shared by: Camerun Peoples (Appalachian State) Rickey Hunt (Ohio) |
2020 2023 |
| Passing touchdowns |
2, shared by: Jason Bean (North Texas) Davis Brin (Tulsa) Cam Fancher (Marshall) Davis Brin (Georgia Southern) Tad Hudson (Coastal Carolina) Broc Lowry (Western Michigan) |
2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 |
| Rushing touchdowns |
5, Camerun Peoples (Appalachian State) |
2020 |
| Receiving touchdowns |
2, shared by: Henry Pearson (Appalachian State) Loronzo Thompson (North Texas) |
2020 |
| Receptions |
8, Josh Johnson (Tulsa) |
2021 |
| Tackles |
13, shared by: Kaiden Smith (Appalachian State) Jason Henderson (Old Dominion) R'Tarriun Johnson (Old Dominion) |
2020 2021 2021 |
| Tackles for loss |
3, shared by: Nick Hampton (Appalachian State) Jordan Young (Old Dominion) Bradley Weaver (Ohio) Martavius French (UTSA) |
2020 2021 2023 2024 |
| Sacks |
2.5, Rodney McGraw (Western Michigan) |
2025 |
| Interceptions |
1, shared by multiple people; most recent: Caleb Offord (Kennesaw State) Joey Pope (Western Michigan) Tate Hallock (Western Michigan) |
2025 |
| Long Plays |
Record, Player, Team |
Year |
| Touchdown run |
70 yds., Marcus Williams Jr. (Appalachian State) |
2020 |
| Touchdown pass |
82 yds., Amari Odom (Kennesaw State) |
2025 |
| Kickoff return |
100 yds., LaMareon James (Old Dominion) |
2021 |
| Punt return |
15 yds., Keegan Wilburn (Georgia Southern) |
2023 |
| Interception return |
75 yds., Joey Pope (Western Michigan) |
2025 |
| Fumble return |
47 yds., Kershawn Fisher (Western Michigan) |
2025 |
| Punt |
56 yds., Caile Hogan (UTSA) |
2024 |
| Field goal |
38 yds., Tate Sandell (UTSA) |
2024 |