Tenuta was selected in the sixth round, 209th overall, of the 2022 NFL draft by the Buffalo Bills.[3][4] On August 30, 2022, he was released by the Bills.[5]
Indianapolis Colts (first stint)
On August 31, 2022, Tenuta was claimed off waivers by the Indianapolis Colts.[6] On October 15, 2022, Tenuta was waived.[7]
Green Bay Packers
On October 18, 2022, Tenuta was claimed off waivers by the Green Bay Packers.[8] He saw his first NFL action on December 25, 2022, playing four special teams snaps in a Week 16 victory over the Miami Dolphins. He was placed on injured reserve on August 31, 2023.[9] He was released on August 27, 2024.[10]