In the Chiefs only season in the ACFL, they finished with a 2-10 record. The teams only wins came against the New York Crusaders and the Western Massachusetts Pioneers in September 1973. The leading scorer for the season was kicker Booth Lusteg with 25 points. Bruce Cerone and Lance George led Long Island with three touchdowns each on the season (18 points).
After experiencing financial problems at the beginning of the season, the team's license was revoked by the league in mid-October and their remaining games were forfeited.[4][5]
↑"End Near For Chiefs?". Newsday. October 4, 1973. p.179. Retrieved July 2, 2025– via Newspapers.com.
↑Oatway, Bob (October 16, 1973). "Crusaders win by a forfeit". The Reporter Dispatch. White Plains, New York. p.28. Retrieved July 2, 2025– via Newspapers.com.