A native of Lakeland, Florida, Beardsley was born to parents Josh and Tiffany Beardsley.[2] She participated in both soccer and cross country before dedicating herself entirely to soccer.[3] Beardsley played club soccer for the West Florida Flames, where she was a starting goalkeeper and club captain.[4] She also played soccer for Lakeland Senior High School while receiving an education.[2]
College career
Georgia Bulldogs
At the start of her career with the Georgia Bulldogs, Beardsley saw little playing time and instead learned from starting goalkeeper Emory Wegener.[5] She was named to the 2021 SEC Academic Honor Roll while in a backup role.[2] Then, as a sophomore, Beardsley was able to rise to a starting position following Wegener's departure and ended up playing in 14 of Georgia's matches before being benched for Jordan Brown.[6][7] She allowed 12 goals and recorded 7 clean sheets.[2][5]
Maryland Terrapins
Leading up to the 2023 season, Beardsley transferred to the University of Maryland.[8] In her first year with the Maryland Terrapins, she led the team in minutes and started all 18 games.[9] She became the first Terrapin to record 6 shutouts in a single season since 2014, and was also named to the CSC Academic All-District Team.[9][10] The following year, Beardsley once again started every single match.[9] She registered 74 saves, 5 shutouts, and captained the team as her college career came to a close.[11]
Club career
Beardsley joined the Houston Dash's preseason squad as a non-rostered invitee ahead of the 2025 NWSL season.[12] On March 11, 2025, Beardsley signed a short-term contract with the Dash,[11][13] which, two months later, was upgraded to a permanent contract through the end of the season.[14] On June 30, 2025, she signed a new deal with Houston through 2027 with a mutual option for an additional year;[15] the very same month, she was placed on the Dash's 45-day injury list and forced to miss a portion of her rookie season.[16]
In January 2026, Beardsley joined USL Super League club Tampa Bay Sun on loan for the entire year.[17] She made her professional debut on January 31,[18] starting in a 2–2 draw with Spokane Zephyr FC to open the second half of Tampa Bay's season.[19]