Hibernian
Fife subsequently joined Hibernian in January 2013.[9][10] Fife was the only player from Murieston signed to Hibernian that year and one of three players picked that had not previously belonged to the Hibernian reserve squad.[10] In April 2013, Fife assisted Hibernian to a win over Hamilton Academical[11] The night before the game the team was surprised to learn their goalkeeper Shannon Lynn had decided to join another team.[11] This development allowed Fife to serve in that capacity for the game.[11] The Scotsman reported: "As a result, Jenna Fife made her first start of the season for the Easter Road girls. Her terrific debut included a first-half penalty save."[11]
In the beginning of 2014 she had a short loan spell at Hutchison Vale, but was recalled to Hibernian in late April of that year.[12][13]
Fife was rivaled in skill by Glasgow City players in a May 2015 game; BBC Sport noted of a significant play during the 3–3 tie game: "Erin Cuthbert laid the ball into the path of Hayley Lauder who instinctively fired an exquisite shot beyond Hibs goalkeeper Jenna Fife."[14] After a 4–0 win against Aberdeen in May 2015, Chris Roberts of Hibernian reflected in an interview published in Edinburgh Evening News: "Aberdeen made full use of the high winds during the first half to put us under pressure. They came at us, went on the attack and although Jenna [Fife] was never really troubled, we were under a fair amount of pressure."[15]
In June 2015, Hibernian faced Glasgow City in the Scottish Women's Premier League Cup with Fife in goal, but were defeated 2–1.[16][17] Edinburgh Evening News wrote of the game: "Hibs would take a narrow lead into the interval although they had to survive a scare when goalkeeper Jenna Fife failed to take Hayley Lauder’s corner kick cleanly and Nicola Docherty stabbed the ball toward goal before Arnot headed off the line."[16] The Herald described Fife's style of football play in the game: "City finally started to show why they have dominated Scottish women's football in the last 15 minutes of the half, but although the otherwise impressive Jenna Fife spilled a corner, the Hibs defence retained their composure to hold out for half time."[17] Stornoway Gazette noted Fife had saved a shot against her in a June 2015 game versus Glasgow City[18] She was bested by Glasgow City players in a June 2015 game, with The Scotsman reporting: "Nicky Docherty sent in a low free-kick with Kerry Montgomery getting the touch which beat Jenna Fife."[19]
In August 2015, her two saves earned Hibernian a 3–3 draw against rivals Glasgow City[20] BBC Sport noted of the game: "It should have been 2–1 when Hayley Lauder slipped through Julie Fleeting, however her first touch was poor and goalkeeper Jenna Fife saved at her feet."[21] The Herald reported: "The high-level entertainment continued with Fife making a good smothering save from Fleeting before Hibs went ahead with a well-worked goal."[22] The newspaper continued to note of Fife's total two saves in the game: "Fife made two great saves just before the hour from O'Sullivan and Lauren McMurchie, but she was then beaten by Docherty's curling shot from the left."[22]
Hibernian lost to Glasgow City in October 2015 with the final score of 2–0.[23] The Herald wrote of the game's slow development: "A tentative game finally found a goal after 57 minutes. Denise O'Sullivan's fine through ball left Lauder clear in the box, and although the Scotland player didn't hit her shot well, it was enough to beat goalkeeper Jenna Fife."[23]
In November 2015, Hiberian faced Glasgow City in the Scottish Women's Premier League Cup but was defeated 3–0 by Glasgow City[24][25] Weather was a serious factor in the game, with The Scotsman noting: "So much so that an early clearance from Hibs goalkeeper Jenna Fife was caught by the wind and almost blown back into her net it was so powerful at times."[25] The Scotsman wrote of Fife's performance during the game: "it was Glasgow City that appeared the more likely to score with former Rangers midfielder Erin Cuthbert desperately unlucky not to notch a goal as she was denied firstly by the crossbar and then a stunning save from Fife."[25]
