| Title | Publication | Collected in |
| "The State of Grace" | The New Yorker (November 6, 1954) | First Love and Other Sorrows |
"Laura" aka "Fanny" | The New Yorker (December 11, 1954) |
| "The Quarrel" | The New Yorker (July 23, 1955) |
"Laurie Dressing" aka "Cassie Dressing" | The New Yorker (November 12, 1955) |
| "Gloria Mundi" | Discovery 6 (1955) | First Love and Other Sorrows (1998 edition) |
| "The Sound of Moorish Laughter" | Harper's (May 1956) |
| "Trio for Three Gentle Voices" | Mademoiselle (July 1956) | First Love and Other Sorrows |
| "Piping Down the Valleys Wild" | The New Yorker (May 11, 1957) |
| "First Love and Other Sorrows" | The New Yorker (June 15, 1957) |
| "Sentimental Education" | The New Yorker (July 6, 1957) |
| "The Dark Woman of the Sonnets" | The New Yorker (August 24, 1957) |
| "The Abundant Dreamer" | The New Yorker (November 23, 1963) | Stories in an Almost Classical Mode |
| "A Well-Regulated Impulse" | Esquire (October 1964) | First Love and Other Stories (1998 edition) |
| "On the Waves" | The New Yorker (September 4, 1965) | Stories in an Almost Classical Mode |
| "Bookkeeping" | The New Yorker (April 27, 1968) |
| "Hofstedt and Jean—and Others" | The New Yorker (January 25, 1969) |
| "The Shooting Range" | The New Yorker (September 13, 1969) |
| "Innocence" | American Review 16 (February 1973) |
| "Play" | American Review 17 (May 1973) |
"A Story in an Almost Classical Mode" aka "Lila" | The New Yorker (September 17, 1973) |
| "His Son, in His Arms, in Light, Aloft" | Esquire (August 1975) |
| "Puberty" | Esquire (December 1975) |
| "Largely an Oral History of My Mother" | The New Yorker (April 26, 1976) |
| "The Pain Continuum" | Partisan Review 43.1 (1976) |
| "Verona: A Young Woman Speaks" | Esquire (July 1977) |
| "Ceil" | The New Yorker (September 12, 1983) |
| "Nonie" | The New Yorker (March 5, 1985) | from The Runaway Soul |
| "S.L." | The New Yorker (September 9, 1985) | Stories in an Almost Classical Mode |
"The Boys on Their Bikes" aka "Falling and Ascending Bodies" | Vanity Fair (March 1985) |
| "Angel" | Women and Angels (1985) |
| "The Bullies" | The New Yorker (June 30, 1986) | The World Is the Home of Love and Death |
"The Nurse's Music" aka "Annemarie Singing" | The New Yorker (August 22, 1988) | Stories in an Almost Classical Mode |
| "Spring Fugue" | The New Yorker (April 23, 1990) | The World Is the Home of Love and Death |
| "A Kingdom of Sadness" | The New Yorker (October 7, 1991) | from The Runaway Soul |
| "What I Do for Money" | The New Yorker (October 18, 1993) | The World Is the Home of Love and Death |
| "Religion" | Glimmer Train 14 (Spring 1995) |
| "Dumbness Is Everything" | The New Yorker (October 7, 1996) |
| "Waking" | The World Is the Home of Love and Death (1997) |
| "Car Buying" |
| "Lila and S.L." |
| "Jibber-Jabber in Little Rock" |
| "The World Is the Home of Love and Death" |
| "A Guest in the Universe" |