Club

Paternoster started his career in the youth team of Atlanta in 1919. He made his breakthrough into the first team in 1921.^[1]

In 1926 Paternoster joined Racing Club de Avellaneda where he played until 1932. Between 1930 and 1931, he was loaned for free by Racing to Vélez Sársfield to play for the club in a Pan-American tour that took them from Chile to the United States.^[2]

In 1936 he made a single appearance for Argentinos Juniors.

National team

Paternoster was part of the Argentina squad that finished runner-up to Uruguay in the 1928 Olympic football tournament.^[3] He played in the 1929 South American Championship, helping Argentina win the title.^[4] In 1930 he was again in an Argentine team that finished as runner up to Uruguay, this time in the 1930 FIFA World Cup. He made a total of 16 appearances for Argentina.

Player

Racing

• Copa de Honor: 1932

Argentina

• Copa América: 1929
• Summer Olympics Silver Medal: 1928
• FIFA World Cup runner-up: 1930

Manager

Atlético Nacional

• Categoría Primera A (1): 1954

Emelec

• Campeonato Ecuatoriano de Futbol (1): 1965